OP-ED: Police Misconduct Harms Everyone,
Part 1
By John B. Greet
According to the California
Innocence Project
“Police misconduct encompasses
illegal or unethical actions or the violation of individuals’ constitutional
rights by police officers in the conduct of their duties.”
Black’s Law Dictionary defines
misconduct, in this context, in part as
“Any unlawful conduct on the
part of a person concerned in the administration of justice which is
prejudicial to the rights of parties or to the right determination of the
cause.”
These definitions, and others
we might find, come close. I would personally define police misconduct as
“Any willful or negligent
violation of an applicable policy, rule, or other regulation; or of any
statutory or case law, when committed by a sworn or civilian, paid or
volunteer, police employee.”
This article deals primarily
with misconduct committed by sworn police officers.
Regardless of the source, and
there are many, I think most people can agree that police misconduct boils down
to a violation of both public trust and professional standards. Misconduct can
take many forms and span a wide spectrum of seriousness.
Some Examples
An officer who, absent a
reasonable justification, fails to file or correct a police report in a timely
manner has committed misconduct, because there exists a policy requiring that
he or she do so.
An officer who parks his or her
car in a red curb and then enters a restaurant to have a meal has committed
misconduct, because there exists a policy prohibiting that and because it is a
clear abuse of his or her authority.
An officer who uses excessive
force in making an arrest has committed misconduct, because there exists a
policy prohibiting that, because it is a clear abuse of his or her authority,
and because it may ultimately be deemed unlawful.
An officer who violates the
civil or constitutional rights of others under color of authority has committed
misconduct, because there exist policies prohibiting that, because it is a
clear abuse of his or her authority, and because it is a violation of both
state and federal law.
Given the number of policies,
rules, regulations, and statutory and case laws that apply to law enforcement,
the number of ways an officer might commit some form of misconduct is
considerable.
Proving and Documenting Police
Misconduct
As I have written in the past,
all police misconduct is wrong and, if proven, should result in the strongest
sanctions that policy and/or law allow. Not all questionable conduct is
automatically misconduct, however, and not all misconduct rises to the level of
a tort or a crime.
As with any offense committed
by anyone else, an offense of police misconduct must be proven to a reasonable
and objective standard before the officer can be punished. I would not presume
to claim that we discover all police misconduct which actually occurs nor that
it all can be proven. Unfortunately, police agencies and the governments of
which they are a part can only deal with the misconduct which comes to their
attention and can only punish the misconduct which can be proven objectively.
Condemning misconduct is
proper. By the same token it seems unreasonable to paint the entire law
enforcement profession, or an entire police department, with a broad brush of
condemnation, because of misconduct committed by a relative few.
To my mind, though, the true
challenge is less in proving misconduct than in accurately documenting the
degree to which it occurs, particularly at the state and national levels.
At LBPD, there exist thorough
Internal Affairs records for every officer who has ever had a formal complaint
filed or opened against him or her. The longer an employee serves, the larger
such files typically, and unfortunately, become. Not necessarily because each
officer commits increased amounts of misconduct, but because they often receive
complaints whether those complaints are valid or not and each complaint has to
be investigated, and each investigation thoroughly documented.
Part of the Internal Affairs
Division’s responsibility is to accurately track complaints against officers in
LBPD and to provide regular and thorough summaries to Chief Luna and his Command
staff.
According to California law,
Internal Affairs files are considered part of police officers’ confidential
personnel records, thus they are not made available to the general public.
Officers have the right to review their own files (under supervision) and
department supervisors, managers, and executives may review them as needed. On
occasion, the City Manager and elected Mayor, Councilmembers, and City Attorney
may also review these files.
To my knowledge, however, there
is no government-managed statewide or nationwide database which tracks police
misconduct. Given the violation of public trust which misconduct represents,
this surprises me. At the very least, State Attorney’s General should collect
related data and then voluntarily share it with the U.S. Attorney General for
the same purpose…tracking police misconduct and analyzing the types that occur
and the discipline typically imposed.
Who Does Misconduct Harm?
First and most importantly, the
recipient of the officer’s misconduct is harmed, whether physically,
financially, or by being unlawfully deprived of his or her rights to some
degree.
Government is harmed. Elected
officials are often extremely frustrated with police misconduct, especially the
very serious sort, which often results in claims against the city for monetary
damages. The Mayor and Council have to approve the settlement of these claims
or agree to have the City Attorney litigate them in the event of a lawsuit.
Payouts for officer misconduct can –and do- cost the city millions and millions
of dollars.
Other cops are harmed. Few
people are more frustrated and angered by bad cops than other police officers.
Those few bad cops among them only make their own jobs that much harder and,
often, far less safe. Given the officers killed and assaulted statistics I
reported in my last Op-Ed, no professional police officer wants his or her job
made any harder or any more uniquely hazardous than it already is.
The people in the community are
harmed. The general public is especially justified in being angry and
frustrated with bad cops. As is well known, the police derive their authority
from the very public they serve. The public asks a great deal of its police
officers and provides them with a great deal of trust, authority, and resources
so they can meet the community’s policing needs. When the police violate their
community’s trust, they slowly begin to lose the public’s support. Without the
public’s moral and financial support, cooperation, and voluntary consent to
submit to police authority, local police departments simply cannot function
effectively and, in severe cases, may be disbanded altogether.
In Part 2 of this article, I
will discuss in greater detail some attempts to quantify and analyze police
misconduct in the United States and highlight some violations of public trust
by former Long Beach Police Officers.
In Part 3 of this article I
will suggest some ways to improve police-community relations, generally and
propose some ways police oversight in Long Beach may be improved.
Op-Ed:
Police Misconduct Harms Everyone, Part 2
By John B. Greet
In Part 1 of this series I
offered several possible definitions for police misconduct and discussed
several of the more general aspects of the topic.
In this part of the series I
list a few specific examples of prior incidents of misconduct at the Long Beach
Police Department (LBPD) as well as some attempts to quantify and analyze
police misconduct throughout the nation.
Examples of past misconduct
Throughout LBPD’s history there
have unfortunately been a number of examples of severe misconduct by its (now
former) officers.
In 2013 a former detective was
arrested and prosecuted for using her position to help a criminal street gang.
In 2013 a former officer
pleaded guilty to several counts of sexual misconduct.
In 2012 a former officer
charged with assaulting his wife was sentenced to 12 years and four months in
state prison.
In 2010 a former officer
pleaded guilty to stealing firearms.
This was not intended to be a
complete or comprehensive listby any means. There are many other regrettable
incidents of proven misconduct by former LBPD officers and, in most every case,
the misconduct occurred while the officers were on duty.
Perspective
Habitual critics of the
department often seem to take great pleasure in posting more comprehensive
lists of this type but seem strangely reluctant to acknowledge that in each
case of police misconduct there exist department policies that prohibit all of
it.
Similarly, these critics often
lack a certain measure of perspective. Instances of any degree of proven
misconduct arguably represent less than 1% of the total activity in which LBPD
officers engage throughout any given year. While all misconduct is wrong and
should be condemned, proven misconduct at LBPD is neither an “epidemic” nor
even “common.” Misconduct is the notable exception to the vast rule of
professional police activity in Long Beach.
As a moderately productive
patrol officer at LBPD, I typically engaged in about 60-70 policing activities
per shift (parking and traffic enforcement, subject contacts, arrests, calls
for service, investigations, reports, etc.) At the time there were about 850
sworn officers in the department. For the sake of argument, let’s say the average
activity level for each officer was 50 per shift, times 850 equals 42,500
police activities per shift department-wide, times about 180 work days per year
equals 7.7 million police activities department-wide per year, times 20 years
equals 154 million police activities over 20 years department-wide.
I challenge anyone to develop a
comprehensive list of proven LBPD misconduct incidents over 20 years, total
them up, compare them with 154 million, and try to convince any reasonable
person that proven misconduct at LBPD is an “epidemic” or even “common.”
Attempts to quantify and
analyze police misconduct
There have been several rather
ad-hoc attempts to quantify and analyze police misconduct over the years in
both the public and the private sectors. In my opinion, none of them have had
much long-term or truly probative value.
Public Sector
The U.S. Department of Justice,
Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS) has conducted a number of surveys and
published reports broadly related to the topic but, to my knowledge, does not
oversee any continuous program to collect and analyze data related to police
misconduct throughout the United States. I believe it should do so. I do not
think the BJS has the constitutional authority to mandate that state and local
agencies share their misconduct complaint data but I do think those agencies
should agree to do so voluntarily.
The State of California
licenses all state and local police officers in the state and also sets
standards for peace officer training through its Commission on Peace Officer
Standards and Training (POST). For this reason and others I think all such
agencies should be required to share their misconduct complaint data with the
State Department of Justice (DoJ). To my knowledge this does not occur and
beyond sometimes investigating crimes committed by police or accepting
misconduct complaints under very limited circumstances, the State DoJ does not
appear to collect any comprehensive data on police misconduct.
The Los Angeles County District
Attorney’s Office has a Justice System Integrity Division which is responsible
for investigating and prosecuting any allegation of criminal misconduct
committed by a peace officer within the county, whether on or off duty.
Investigators and Deputy D.A.’s from this Division also respond on all
officer-involved hit shootings in the county and investigate them concurrently
with, but independently from, the involved agency and, in the case of
fatalities, with the County Coroner’s Office. Again, though, the District
Attorney does not appear to collect or analyze data of officer misconduct
within the county.
Private Sector
The most common result of a
standard Boolean search related to Officer Misconduct reporting and tracking
appears to be a project the CATO Institute currently produces called the
National Police Misconduct Reporting Project (NPMRP.) NPMRP began in 2009 as a
private project but the owner transferred the rights to CATO in 2012. NPMRP
offers a number of valuable resources and provides a “Daily Feed” of misconduct
reports from around the nation. Although part of the original intent of NPMRP
was to document police misconduct on an ongoing and comprehensive basis, the
project has produced only two such reports, in 2009 and 2010, and no reports at
all since CATO assumed control of the effort in 2012.
Unfortunately, as a serious
study of police misconduct NPMRP has limited value because its reports only
document alleged misconduct and from only a small percentage of the total
agencies throughout the nation. There is no data on the results of any
subsequent administrative or criminal investigations, and only sparse data on
the arrests, convictions, and incarceration rates of former police officers.
Sadly, these reports are far from the comprehensive or objective sort that
might provide serious public policy researchers with much in the way of
valuable information.
In Part 3 of this article I
will suggest some ways to improve police-community relations, generally and
propose some ways police oversight in Long Beach may be improved.
Editor's note: the views
expressed in this OP-ED do not necessarily reflect those of the Long
Beach
Post, its staff, or its ownership. To submit a letter to the editor or an
OP-ED, please email editor@lbpost.com .
Baltimore mayor seeks more federal aid to combat police misconduct
By Mark Puente
As calls persist for greater
police accountability in communities across the nation, Mayor Stephanie
Rawlings-Blake told a White House panel Tuesday that the city needs money for
increased training and body cameras, and to add supervisors to the office that
investigates misconduct..
"This creates a higher
level of accountability in the investigations and ensures that officers are
being held accountable for their actions," the mayor told President Barack
Obama's Task Force on 21st Century Policing. "Having grant funding to pay
for those positions would expedite the process."
Rawlings-Blake told the
12-member panel that she is committed to improving the relationship between
police and Baltimore's residents. While crime has dropped in recent years, the
problem of police misconduct continues to overshadow such improvements, she
said.
Residents were "concerned about the tactics
used by police officers in order to achieve the crime reductions we were
experiencing," she added.
Her comments followed testimony
from Sacramento Mayor Kevin Johnson and Philadelphia Mayor Michael Nutter, who
also told the panel about problems plaguing their police forces.
Obama created the task force in
December to explore ways to build public trust and promote reductions in crime.
He also proposed using millions in federal funding to help pay for body cameras
for 50,000 police officers across the country.
The president's announcement
followed nationwide protests over the police-involved deaths of Michael Brown
in Missouri, Eric Garner in New York City and Tamir Rice in Cleveland. Those
incidents have stoked anger in many communities about the treatment of
minorities by police.
More protests are planned in
Baltimore and in Annapolis on Thursday, a day after the 2015 General Assembly
session opens.
The task force, which met
Tuesday at the Newseum, is headed by Philadelphia Police Commissioner Charles
Ramsey and Laurie Robinson, a former assistant attorney general who is a
co-chair of the International Association of Chiefs of Police Research Advisory
Committee. The group is scheduled to complete a report within 90 days.
Nutter and Johnson, president
of the U.S. Conference of Mayors, told the panel that many U.S. cities face
conflicts between police and residents.
"The issues that we're
discussing today are primarily local issues," Johnson said. "We
cannot pretend there is a one-size–fits-all-model" for solutions.
"Nothing can be achieved
without mutual respect and the shared vision of destiny," Nutter said.
Nutter and Johnson — like
Rawlings-Blake — are working to reform their police departments.
Johnson has ordered his police
chief to provide a report with recommendations for overhauling the department.
Johnson wants the chief to explore the use of body cameras, ways to diversify
the force, improvements in training and opportunities to better relations with
the community.
The police departments in
Baltimore and Philadelphia also are undergoing comprehensive reviews by the
U.S. Department of Justice.
A recent multi-part Baltimore
Sun investigation revealed that the city's police officers have battered dozens
of residents — resulting in broken bones, head trauma, organ failure, and even
death — during questionable arrests. Some residents were beaten while
handcuffed; others were thrown to the pavement. The city has paid $5.7 million
in court judgments and settlements in 102 civil suits alleging police brutality
and other misconduct since 2011. And in almost every case, prosecutors or
judges dismissed the charges against the people who were arrested — if charges
were filed at all.
The investigation also found
that some Baltimore officers were involved in multiple lawsuits alleging
brutality, and city officials were unaware of the scope of the problem because
they lacked comprehensive tracking systems for police misconduct. Five days
after the first part of The Sun investigation was published, Police
Commissioner Anthony W. Batts announced that he had asked the Justice
Department to help reform the agency. The collaborative review is in its early
stages.
Federal officials intervened a
year ago in Philadelphia to help curb outrage over years of officer-involved
shootings.
Rawlings-Blake told the panel
that "building trust and legitimacy are at the forefront of what we have
been working to improve in Baltimore."
She pointed out that complaints
and lawsuits against Baltimore officers have decreased, and that more residents
are providing crime tips to police. "We have demonstrated that Baltimore
can learn from its past."
Rawlings-Blake also told the
panel she is committed to impartiality, legitimacy and procedural justice when
it comes to police interactions with residents. The department is adding ethics
and situational training to give officers hands-on experience when confronting
problems on the streets.
"The goal is building a
belief in every officer that a safe neighborhood can't be achieved without the
trust and confidence that comes from community engagement," said
Rawlings-Blake, vice president of the U.S. Conference of Mayors.
While the city is working to
create a program to equip officers with body cameras, Rawlings-Blake said, such
cameras are a necessity to hold officers accountable and to defend them against
false accusations. Federal funding could help Baltimore become one of the first
major cities with a comprehensive program for its officers, she said.
The Justice Department's review
will bring consultants to Baltimore this month to start examining the police
force, and the mayor said an increased federal partnership is crucial to
helping train officers on issues like diversity.
"They need to learn more
than logistics of policing, but also the broader significance of their role in
our society," she said.
After the three mayors had
spoken, Rawlings-Blake said she is "optimistic" that Congress and
Obama will act on the task force's findings. She also urged more cities to ask
the Justice Department for help to improve training for police forces.
"This work is not going to
happen on its own," she said.
And yet people deny that we have to many cops with too much time on their hands: Man cited for 'eating while driving' in Georgia
Rachel Stockman
WSB-TV – Atlanta
COBB COUNTY, Ga. — An Alabama
man says he was cited by police in Cobb County, Georgia, for “eating while
driving” under the distracted driving law.
Madison Turner said he ordered
a double Quarter Pounder with cheese from McDonald’s last week, and a police
officer pulled him over in Marietta, an Atlanta suburb.
“The officer explained to me
that he observed me eating a burger for two miles,” Turner said. “He said
specifically three times, 'You can’t just go down the road eating a
hamburger.'"
According to the ticket, the
officer wrote him up under Georgia’s distracted driving law and under the
comments section wrote, “eating while driving.”
That law reads, in part: “A
driver shall exercise due care in operating a motor vehicle on the highways of
this state and shall not engage in any actions which shall distract such driver
from the safe operation of such vehicle.”
Maybe I was enjoying the burger too much; I
needed to tone it down. I was certainly willing to do so, but I didn’t expect
to be fined or punished,” Turner said.
“If this was the law, I’d have
to hire more attorneys because everybody does it including me,” said William
Head, a longtime traffic and DUI attorney, who is not representing Turner.
“I’ve only seen something like
this charge when there’s an accident.
There was no accident here so the fact that this man was charged with
eating and driving is a first for me,” Head said. Head added that law was very
vague.
“Maybe if you had a giant pizza
in both hands and you weren’t holding the wheel, or maybe if you had a
watermelon – half watermelon – and you were just diving into it holding it with
both hands, maybe that would be something,” Head said.
A representative for Cobb
County police said they could not comment, since the case is ongoing. Madison
has a court date on Feb. 3.
What Cardinal Dolan, my friend, must learn about the NYPD and the community Dolan sees police as his people in a way he can't see Eric Garner of Michael Brown as his people
BY DONNA SCHAPER
Jesus is the one who refused to
have an enemy. He also understood the fantasies of peace: “Peace, peace, when
there is no peace.”
I want to bring Jesus into this
leaderless mess we call New York City. I want to invite his refusal to have an
enemy into the audacity of those who think they are too big.
I think of Timothy Cardinal
Dolan, whose recent editorials in the Daily News made him too big.
As a Protestant, once again, I
beg to differ with spiritual meritocracy. Cardinal Dolan is not my enemy. He is
my friend, as are policemen, as are Eric Garner and Michael Brown.
I am not here to pick a fight
with Cardinal Dolan. Without naming him, the cardinal did criticize the actions
of Pat Lynch, head of the policeman’s union. I honor him for that criticism and
understand it probably cost him in certain quarters. I have read and re-read
his three public statements of recent months and each time tried to understand
what it must be like to feel like you have to defend the police at this time in
our city.
I understand the meaning of
constituency. I understand social position. I have often had flare-ups with
congregants who felt they needed protection, so deep were they within the
victim stance. “The real victim is not so and so, the real victim is me.” You
know the drill.
You ask for unity but you ask
for it from your perspective and the perspective of your people. That is what
the cardinal is doing. He wants unity at a table where he is the host and you
are the guest.
That kind of unity is not what
Jesus wanted.
He wanted a unity where
everybody at the table was a host and everybody was a guest, in a place where
the power differentials were recognized, not minimized.
Discovering that nearly all the
films nominated for awards had white male directors and starred white men is
not something for which anyone can take personal responsibility. Instead it
does show how deep our race-tinged glasses are. There was no conspiracy there.
It’s just the way things are.
There is also no surprise in
Cardinal Dolan thinking he has to defend the police. He sees them as his people
in a way he can’t see Eric Garner or Michael Brown as his people. The cardinal
doesn’t know how to see from the middle and mess of the table.
Another matter begs our Jesus
eyes right now. The way the mayor was disrespected — at memorial services —
shows just how deep the victimized privilege is about the police. They too feel
horribly disrespected. And so the cycle of disrespect clogs our arteries.
The Pope may think his
cardinals have spiritual Alzheimer’s, as he said in his Christmas message. But
Cardinal Dolan has arteriosclerosis, the hardening of the heart’s arteries. He
is not the only one with heart disease but he has more power than most people
with heart disease.
How do I criticize the cardinal
without demonizing him? How do I criticize the policemen who turned their backs
on the mayor without demonizing them?
How do we follow the Jesus who
refuses to have an enemy?
The disease of the moment goes
like this: If you support the community, you are against the police. If you
support the mayor, you are against the police. The opportunities to be against
someone multiply while the opportunities to be for something seem to be
radically decreasing.
“Peace, peace, when there is no
peace.”
In a mess this size, why not
follow Jesus, and refuse to have an enemy? And refuse to give up on the ones
who disrespect you? Refuse to give up on the ones who shoot you. Refuse to give
up on the ones who stop and frisk you. If you are white, understand that we
have heart disease. We have chosen our own to win the prizes. And we didn’t
even know we were doing it.
We need spiritual angioplasty,
the kind Dr. King performed, unsuccessfully to date, on the nation. We need our
arteries opened up.
Schaper is senior minister at
Judson Memorial Church. Excerpted from a sermon she will deliver Monday.
Paddy was stopped by the police around 2:00 am
Paddy was stopped by the police around
2:00 am and was asked where he was going at that time of night.
Paddy replied, "I'm on my way to a
lecture about alcohol abuse and the effects it has on the human body, as well
as smoking and staying out late".
The officer asked, "Really? - Who would
be giving such a lecture at this time of the night?"
Paddy replied, "That would be my
wife".
While most Americans approve of the work being done by their local police, nearly a third feel that some officers “routinely lie to serve their own interests,” a survey released by Reuters
While most Americans approve of the
work being done by their local police, nearly a third feel that some officers
“routinely lie to serve their own interests,” a survey released on Thursday by
Reuters and the IPSOS polling organization showed.
The number rises to 45 percent among
African-Americans.
The findings come as scrutiny on police
has been heightened in recent months by the killing of unarmed blacks by white
officers, which has raised questions about police treatment of racial
minorities.
While distrust is significant, nearly
three-quarters of respondents approve the job done by their local police, the
survey said. The survey showed that 56 percent of African-American respondents
approved of their local police.
MarQuis McClee, a small-business owner
from Bloomington, Indiana, who took part in the poll, said that he generally
trusts police and has officers among his relatives, but as an African-American,
he can also be wary around law enforcement.
"I have been involved with
officers who give police a bad name," McClee, 38, said, pointing to a
recent incident where he was pulled over by an officer be believes was
profiling him.
Nearly 70 percent of African-American respondents
believe that police target minorities.
In November, simmering tensions
exploded with violent protests in several U.S. cities following a grand jury
decision not to indict a police officer in the St. Louis suburb of Ferguson for
shooting an unarmed black teenager.
When asked about the Ferguson police,
60 percent of respondents had a favorable impression but among black American
respondents, only 32 percent had a favorable impression.
When a gunman fatally shot two police
officers in New York in December in apparent retribution attack, the public was
reminded of the dangers police face on a daily basis in trying to keep the
streets safe.
While attention on policing has been in
the spotlight, racial disparity in the criminal justice systems has become a
fact of life in the United States. A study by the Sentencing Project research
group showed that one in three black men are likely to be imprisoned sometime
during their life. The figure for white man is one in 17.
Proactive tactics aimed at keeping
crime rates down in economically stressed areas with a high number of racial
minorities can also cause friction between police and minority youth who are
likely to be stopped and questioned, said Larry Hoover, director of the Police
Research Center at Sam Houston State University in Texas.
10 to 1 he gets away with it
Police chief who accidentally
shot his wife as she slept has been married FOUR times as it emerges she is now
paralyzed from the waist down
• William McCollom, the chief of police in Peachtree City,
Georgia, called 911 on January 1 to say he had accidentally shot his wife,
Margaret
• She is recovering and told investigators she believes it
was accidental
• On the 911 call, it took two minutes for him to admit to
the dispatcher that he was the chief of police
• The incident has sparked a criminal probe and an
investigation into his four decades working for law enforcement
• It has emerged he has been married four times; Margaret
was his third wife and after he recently divorced his fourth wife, they
reconciled
A police chief who accidentally
shot his wife as she slept in their Atlanta home early on New Year's Day has
been married four previous times, an investigation has revealed.
William McCollom, the chief of
police in Peachtree City, told authorities that his gun accidentally went off
as he moved it in the night and now agents from the Georgia Bureau of
Investigation and a local prosecutor are conducting a criminal probe and
examining his career.
His wife, Margaret McCollom,
whom he had previously divorced, is paralyzed from the waist down following the
incident, WSBTV reported. She was released from Atlanta Medical Center earlier
this week.
She told investigators she
cannot shed light on the incident because she was sleeping but that she
believes it was an accident.
Records show that her husband
waited nearly two minutes into the 911 call to mention where he worked.
'You're the chief of police in
Peachtree City?' the dispatcher repeated.
'Yeah, unfortunately, yes,' he
responded.
As soon as the bullet struck
his wife, McCollom's personal life and three-decade history in law enforcement
were bound for intense scrutiny. As the investigation into his past commences,
he also faces an internal inquiry that could result in discipline.
McCollom has gone through four
divorces, including one from Margaret McCollom. It's unclear whether William
and Margaret McCollom ever remarried, though investigators refer to them as
husband and wife.
None of McCollom's divorce
filings indicate he had ever been violent. He married two of the women in
Wyoming, where they remain, and had three children with one.
His fourth wife, previously
named by DailyMail.com as Suzanne Carter, is a rabbi who was the police
department chaplain in Delray Beach, Florida when McCollo, was chief there.
They married in 2002 and
divorced in 2014 after she claims he cheated on her, which he denied.
On the professional front,
hundreds of pages of records from his personnel files contain no evidence of
criminality, major misconduct or recklessness for the former firearms
instructor who once trained a SWAT team on combat shooting.
'Everybody's scratching their
head,' said Michael Couzzo Jr., the village manager who hired McCollom as the
police chief in Tequesta, Florida, in 2006. 'They're scratching their heads
saying, "How could this have happened?"'
Investigators have not publicly
speculated on what led up to the shooting.
Only a few details are known.
McCollom called 911 around 4:17 a.m. and told a dispatcher his handgun fired as
he moved it. McCollom also said he and his wife were sleeping.
He told the 911 dispatcher that
he had shot his wife, a former emergency-room nurse, twice with his
police-issued Glock 9 mm handgun. But it was later determined that she had only
been hit once.
Mrs McCollom told investigators
she was sleeping when shot and couldn't offer more information. The wife said
she thought the shooting was an accident, GBI spokeswoman Sherry Lang said.
If investigators deem the
shooting an accident, a police officer might avoid criminal charges and could
potentially keep his job, said Robert Verry, a longtime internal affairs
investigator in New Jersey and policing instructor. He is not involved in the
probe.
'It's so premature it's tough
to tell,' Verry said. 'The devil's in the details.'
Born in northeast Wyoming,
McCollom, 57, briefly served as a reserve deputy in Cheyenne, Wyoming, in late
1982, according to his resume. County officials could not immediately determine
whether employment records from that period still exist.
McCollom twice married women in
Wyoming, including his second wife, with whom he had three children. Both of
those marriages ended in divorce.
He found a job in 1983 as a
police officer in Delray Beach, Florida, where he worked for 23 years. He rose
through the ranks, eventually becoming the assistant chief.
'His tactics were safe,' said
Delray Beach Police Lt. Vinnie Gray, a union representative who served on the
SWAT team with McCollom. 'It was a shock to see what happened' in Georgia.
In 1988, as McCollom's career
accelerated, he wed Margaret. They divorced 11 years later.
The FBI investigated McCollom
around 1993 over an allegation he knocked out the front teeth of a suspect
arrested for battery on a police officer, McCollom said in a job application.
Old booking photos showed the
accuser did not have teeth prior to the arrest. McCollom said the booking photo
from the arrest in question did not show any injuries.
'The facts and independent
witness testimony proved the subject was lying and the investigation exonerated
me after my initial interview,' McCollom wrote.
McCollom was disciplined once
in 2005 after being accused of ordering a subordinate to request free hotel
rooms for deputy sheriffs, according to his internal affairs file. Delray Beach
Police Chief Larry Schroeder, who counseled McCollom over it, did not return
messages seeking comment.
McCollom got hired as chief of
the small department in Tequesta in 2006, but life drew him back to Wyoming. In
early 2010, McCollom sought unpaid leave, telling colleagues he needed to care
for an ailing sister and help a family construction business.
'I have an opportunity to enter
the private sector as an independent contractor and have decided it is now or
never,' McCollom wrote in a resignation letter.
His fourth wife filed for
divorce in March 2011. Around that time, his former wife, Margaret, rejoined
him in Wyoming, said the chief's sister, Barbara Sutherland.
Sutherland said she believed
the couple remarried after he took the police chief's job in Georgia.
'The second time around, they
grew up, they figured it out,' she said.
Again, we need national IQ standards for cops
LI police recruit accidentally
shoots self during drill
UNIONDALE, N.Y. (AP) —
Authorities say a Long Island police recruit accidentally shot himself in the
leg during a training session at a shooting range. Nassau County police say the
officer pierced his thigh and calf with a single round from his service weapon.
New Mexico police officers face murder charges in shooting death of homeless man
Two New Mexico police officers
accused of killing a homeless man will be charged with murder, the state's
district attorney announced on Monday. They are the first charges against
Albuquerque officers in connection with shootings.
James Boyd, a 36-year-old
homeless man diagnosed as schizophrenic, was shot by the Albuquerque PD after
he became engaged in a four-hour standoff with the officers who caught him
illegally camping in the Sandia foothills. Boyd was armed with two small
knives, which he appeared to brandish towards an officer with a dog. He was
pronounced dead the next day.
At a press conference five days
after the shooting, Chief Gorden Eden told reporters that he believed the
shooting was justified because Boyd made a “threatening” move toward the
officer with the dog. Boyd had an extensive criminal past, and mentioned
killing the police earlier during the encounter.
Bernalillo County District
Attorney Kari Brandenburg filed paperwork Monday charging former Albuquerque
Police Department (APD) Detective Keith Sandy and APD SWAT Team member
Dominique Perez with one open count of murder each in the March 2014 shooting
death of Boyd.
Sandy and Perez will face a
preliminary hearing before a judge who will decide whether there is enough
evidence to proceed with the charges, Brandenburg’s office said in an email
release. No date has been set for the court hearing, the Albuquerque Journal
reported.
Brandenburg filed the charges
via criminal information papers, allowing her to charge the officers without
presenting evidence to a grand jury. Grand juries have declined to indict law
enforcement agents in several high-profile, officer-involved shooting deaths
over the last several months, including in the cases of Michael Brown and Eric
Garner, leading to widespread protests across the country.
Lawyers for the two men argued
that they will both be cleared of wrongdoing.
Sandy “had not only the right,
but the duty to defend a fellow officer from a mentally unstable, violent man
wielding two knives. Keith did nothing wrong,” his attorney Sam Bregman said in
a statement. “To the contrary, he followed his training and probably saved his
fellow officer’s life.”
“This is truly a shame.
Throughout his career, Officer Perez has been called upon to make life-altering
decisions while protecting Albuquerque citizens and his fellow officers,”
attorney Luis Robles said in a statement to KRQE. “And having made one of those
decisions, Officer Perez now faces an open count of murder. Regardless, I am
confident that the facts will vindicate Officer Perez’s actions in this case.”
According to the Huffington
Post, Sandy was fired from the New Mexico State Police in 2007 over allegations
of fraud.
The APD has been under fire
since the Boyd shooting. Less than a week after the homeless man’s death, the
department released video footage taken from the helmet-cam of an officer on
the scene of the crime that shows a cop opening fire on Boyd while his back was
turned. He was the first of three shooting deaths involving the department in
five weeks: On March 25, the APD shot and killed another man, Alfred Redwine,
following an armed stand-off. Three weeks later, Albuquerque police shot and
killed Mary Hawkes, who was suspected of stealing a truck.
The US Department of Justice
conducted a 16-month review into the police department in New Mexico’s largest
city, and recommended a “systematic change” in the final document. The early April
report found that the APD had fallen into a pattern of using force more often
than necessary which, consequently, caused a number of unjustified fatal
shootings by officers in recent years.
APD has been involved in more
than 40 shootings since 2010, resulting in 27 deaths, the Journal reported.
In October, the police
department reached a deal with the Department of Justice to overhaul many of
its practices. The reforms involve new training and recruitment procedures and
field supervision of officers, and will require the department to employ body
cameras on its officers. Additionally, the APD will begin monitoring every use
of a Taser, and officers will have to report every time they point a gun at
another individual, regardless of whether or not it is fired.
Former Savannah-Chatham Police Officer Indicted on Drug Conspiracy Charge
U.S. Attorney’s Office January
08, 2015 • Southern District of Georgia (912)
652-4422
SAVANNAH, GA—Derrick Andre
Fullmer, 27, of Pooler, Georgia, was indicted this week by a federal grand jury
sitting in Savannah on charges related to a conspiracy involving the illegal
possession and distribution of the controlled substance MDMA, more commonly
known as “ecstasy” or “molly.” Fullmer was charged with conspiring to
distribute molly as well as aiding and abetting other conspirators. During much
of the time of the charged conspiracy, Fullmer was an officer with the
Savannah-Chatham Metropolitan Police Department (SCMPD).
Fullmer was arraigned before
United States Magistrate Judge G.R. Smith today. The charge against Fullmer
carries a 20-year maximum prison sentence. U.S. Attorney Ed Tarver emphasized
that an indictment is only an accusation and is not evidence of guilt. The
defendant is entitled to a fair trial, during which it will be the government’s
burden to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
The investigation of this case
was conducted by the FBI, the Chatham Savannah Counter Narcotics Team (CNT) and
SCMPD. Assistant United States Attorney Scarlett S. Nokes is prosecuting the
case on behalf of the United States. For additional information, please contact
First Assistant United States Attorney James D. Durham at (912) 201-2547.
Family dog killing;the national sport of America's cops
Chandler
Police officers shoot dog; family says it wasn't necessary
By
Nicole Garcia, FOX 10 News
CHANDLER,
Ariz. - A Chandler family is demanding answers from Chandler Police after
officers opened fired on their dog killing it, even though it was in their own
yard.
Caution:
the video attached to this story is graphic and may not be suitable for all
audiences.
That
family is very emotional, and an internal investigation is launched after the
officer killed the dog when it was fighting with another dog inside its fenced
enclosure.
"I
don't see again, his need to walk 12 feet from the sidewalk to an enclosure and
shoot my dog," said Javier Robles.
Robles
is 3-year-old Simone's owner, Simone is one of the familys pit bulls. She was
inside the enclosure when the officer shot him. He said his 3-year-old daughter
saw the shooting from inside the home, and now she is traumatized.
"She
says that her doggie blew up, that she hates cop; she woke up having a
nightmare last night saying that her doggie blew up, she's been crying all
day," he said.
Chandler
Police said they got two 911 calls about two dogs fighting. When they arrived
they found one dog had the other dogs face in his mouth. The dogs were
separated by the fence and when one officer could not separate the dogs using a
baton the other officer shot Simone.
But
Robles doubts the officers account of what happened. "It's physically
impossible for a pit bull to fit its mouth threw that small opening, the blood,
you see there and on the floor, is from the officer, you can even see brain
fragments because the officer blew my dogs brains out. Right here, point
blank," said Robles.
He
recorded a confrontation with officers who refused to tell him why they shot
his dog.
Robles
says he has surveillance video of the shooting. Police could not say whether
the dogs threatened the officers, neither officer was injured.
An
investigation into the shooting is underway as is an internal investigation
into the use of force by officers. The officer who opened fire, remains on duty
during both investigations.
This weeks child molestation by cop
Former
Vernonia police officer arrested on child luring charges
By
FOX 12 Staff
VERNONIA,
OR (KPTV) -
A
62-year-old former police officer in Vernonia is accused of sending a sexually
explicit message to a 13-year-old girl.
Gene
Baska was arrested Wednesday on felony charges of luring a minor and attempt to
commit sex abuse.
According
to investigators, Baska sent a "sexually explicit message transmitted
digitally" to the girl.
Deputies
obtained a search warrant Wednesday for his home on Keasey Road and seized
electronic equipment related to the ongoing investigation. The warrant was for
digital images, videos, photos, audio recordings, text messages and call
records.
According
to the Vernonia Police Department, Baska served on the force full-time starting
in 1990 and did volunteer work prior to that. He retired from the department in
2003.
He
bailed out of jail Wednesday night with a no-contact order for the 13-year-old
girl and her family.
Deputies
said there could be more victims. Anyone with information about this case is
asked to call the Columbia County Sheriff's Office tip line at 503-366-4698.
Fort Worth officer accused of lying about role in case is fired
BY
DEANNA BOYD
FORT
WORTH
A
police officer has been fired for allegedly failing to show up at a court for
an aggravated kidnapping trial and giving conflicting information about his
role in the case.
The
indefinite suspension of Officer Royce Brown, who had been with the department
since August 2008, took effect Monday, according to a disciplinary letter filed
with the Civil Service Commission.
Brown
has appealed, said Terry Daffron Porter, his attorney with the Combined Law
Enforcement Associations of Texas.
“I
am anxious to get a hold of the investigation as I already have serious
concerns with the method in which it was conducted,” Daffron Porter said. “He
looks forward to his appeal hearing.”
According
to the disciplinary letter, signed by now retired Chief Jeff Halstead, a
Tarrant County assistant district attorney had told Brown in July that she
needed to speak with him about his involvement in recovering a firearm used in
an aggravated kidnapping case.
Brown,
according to the letter, told the prosecutor he didn’t recall anything about
the firearm and that he only provided security at the scene. The attorney
replied that she might need to speak with him again later, the letter states.
But,
the letter alleges, Brown later did not returns calls or an email from the
attorney, in which he was informed he was needed in court.
Later,
a police supervisor learned that the prosecutor did not want Brown to testify
in court after learning that he had a prior suspension from the department for
untruthfulness.
Brown,
according to the letter, denied receiving any of the voice mail messages and
later told investigators that he did have a second conversation with the
prosecutor — a conversation she denies took place.
In
a later interview with investigators, Brown said he tried to call the
prosecutor but the call taker was unable to transfer him. He provided
investigators with phone records showing he called the district attorney’s
office but at a number different from the one provided by the prosecutor.
“He
submitted his phone records and his phone records bore out the fact that he did
call the DA’s office,” Daffron Porter said.
The
letter alleges that Brown also dramatically changed his account of his role in
the aggravated kidnapping case in separate interviews with investigators.
“Officer
Brown abandoned his obligation as an officer to testify in a criminal case that
could have possibly helped with the conviction of a felon,” according to the
letter.
The
letter states that Brown was also untruthful to both the prosecutor and
internal investigators about discovering evidence in the case. He denied to
investigators finding the gun in question in the aggravated kidnapping case
despite contradictory statements from multiple witnesses, the letter states.
“Officer
Brown’s integrity could always play a part in court cases, which could make him
not useful in court cases that he needs to testify in,” the letter states.
Brown
had previously received a 16-day suspension from the department on allegations
of failing to devote time/attention to duty, untruthfulness, improper use of a
police communications system, and disabling data components on a police
vehicle, the letter states.
Give an idiot a gun, the idiot will use the gun
2 Tioga officers charged, suspended over gun
incident
By
Williston Herald
TIOGA,
N.D. - Two Tioga police officers face felony charges over a training session
during which an AK-47 was fired into a landfill.
The
incident happened June 19, as brothers Joshua and Nathaniel McNally were
getting ready to tee off on the third hole at the Tioga Golf Course, when their
game was interrupted by gunfire.
The
gunfire came from two on-duty Tioga police officers, Sgt. Jeremiah Johnson and
Officer Joshua Nelson. Johnson was training Nelson at the time.
They
both face face Class C felony reckless endangerment charges and have been
placed on paid administrative leave as a result.
Charges
were filed Dec. 31 by Divide County State's Attorney Jordan Seymour.
According
to Tioga police department administrator Jeff Spivey, Tioga Chief Larry Maize
was not aware of the charges being filed until the Williston Herald made a
freedom of information request involving the incident.
There is no national IQ test for cops and here's what happens as a result....and your tax dollars pay for it
Albuquerque
police officer shot by fellow officer during drug bust
By
Joseph J. Kolb
ALBUQUERQUE
(Reuters) - An Albuquerque police officer shot and critically wounded a fellow
officer during an undercover narcotics bust at a fast food franchise parking
lot at around mid-day on Friday, police said.
Police
would not release additional details of the shooting or of the nature of the
officer's injuries.
"Both
officers involved were working in a plain clothes, undercover capacity and have
been with the department for many years," said Albuquerque Police
Department spokeswoman Celina Espinoza said, adding that two suspects were
arrested.
The incident comes after a federal
investigation concluded the police department in the mid-sized U.S. city in New
Mexico used excessive, even deadly, force against passive civilians.
In October of last year, Albuquerque and the
U.S. Justice Department announced an agreement for the city's police department
to undergo reform and be monitored for use of excessive force.
Another police officer was shot during a
traffic stop on Jan. 3. On Dec. 15, an Albuquerque police officer accidentally
shot a bystander when his weapon discharged as he climbed through a window
during a burglary investigation.
The
officer in Friday's underwent surgery at University of New Mexico Hospital,
Espinoza said. A second undercover officer was treated and released from the
hospital with minor injuries. She said she did not know the cause of the
injuries.
Wallace
Anderson, who was inside the restaurant at the time of the shooting, told
broadcaster KOB 4 he saw two unmarked cars pull up.
"They
surrounded this vehicle so it couldn't back up and escape. At that point, the
shots happened and a guy was dragged to the pavement," Anderson said.
(Reporting
by Joseph J. Kolb in Albuquerque, New Mexico; Editing by Robert Birsel)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)













