BY GRAHAM RAYMAN NEW YORK DAILY NEWS
Hayden Holder claims off-duty cop
started 2013 brawl that left him in jail waiting trial
An off-duty police sergeant
severely pummeled by a Queens man in 2013 actually started the fight and he was
extremely drunk, his blood-alcohol level more than three times the legal limit.
Now the man who delivered the
beating hopes the revelations — based on witness interviews, newly released
video and hospital records — shed new light on a criminal case that once
appeared a slam dunk. But union leaders say that even if then-Sgt. Mohamed Deen
started the fight, the physical response was so violent that any claim of
self-defense disappeared in the midst of the street fight.
In November 2013, auto mechanic
Hayden Holder decked Deen with one punch outside a gyro joint on Liberty Ave.
in Ozone Park, Queens. Then Holder pounced on the cop, hitting him 11 more
times in the pre-dawn hours. Deen, 42, had bleeding on the brain and needed
surgery to repair broken bones in his face. He was in a medically induced coma
for several days.
Police and prosecutors said
Holder, 32, was trying to kill Deen. They said the attack came out of nowhere.
A video uploaded to YouTube shows
Hayden Holder attacking Mohamed Deen in 2013. Holder claims that he was acting
in self-defense.
A video uploaded to YouTube shows
Hayden Holder attacking Mohamed Deen in 2013. Holder claims that he was acting
in self-defense.
“It’s really hard to overstate
the savageness of this attack,” prosecutor John Ruane said during Holder’s Nov.
18, 2013, arraignment, as cops packed the courtroom.
Holder, a mechanic with no prior
criminal record, says Deen initiated the whole thing — first outside the
Maracas nightclub on Jamaica Ave. in Richmond Hill, and then later about a mile
south outside the Liberty Express gyro spot.
“I had no idea who this guy was,
I had never seen him before,” Holder said. “I had no idea he was a cop.”
Indeed, security video from the
nightclub shows that Deen suddenly walked up to Holder and became more and more
enraged, ultimately ripping off his shirt and coming at Holder with his fists
clenched and biceps bulging.
Holder's mother, Madonna Jagdeo —
shown here with her husband, Patrick — said that their son was trying to hold
himself back during the assault.
In November, 2013, auto mechanic
Hayden Holder (pictured) decked then-Sgt. Muhamad Deen with one punch outside a
gyro joint and then hit him as many as 11 more times in the pre-dawn hours on
Liberty Ave. in Ozone Park.
Enlarge
Holder's mother, Madonna Jagdeo —
shown here with her husband, Patrick — said that their son was trying to hold
himself back during the brutal assault.
Bouncers pulled Deen away, but he
tried to get at Holder twice more, before unsuccessfully lunging at him. The
sergeant left when cops arrived.
Jamaica Hospital records show
that Deen had a blood-alcohol level of .26. Even while off-duty, police
officers are supposed to be fit for work, according to NYPD regulations.
Throughout most of the
five-minute encounter captured on video, Holder had his arms behind his back
and just stood there.
“He’s got his hands behind his
back, and he’s trying avoid the man,” his stepfather Patrick Jagdeo, 45, said.
“You can see it on the video.”
Holder and his friend, Bernard
Joseph, 33, hung around briefly and then left to go to the Liberty Express gyro
joint, which was one of the only restaurants open in the area at that hour.
“As we were walking to the car,
we were like, ‘This is why we don’t come to clubs, because people don’t know
how to handle their liquor,’" Joseph recalled.
Once there, Holder ordered two
gyros for himself and Joseph, and bought sodas. As Holder walked back to the
car, Deen pulled up, Joseph said.
As a result of the attack, Sgt.
Mohamed Deen had to be put in a medically induced coma for several days. He had
bleeding on the brain and needed surgery to repair broken bones in his face.
It may have been a random
encounter, but Holder and his family believe Deen followed him there to
confront him again.
“That’s where they meet, and
Deen’s yelling at him and threatening him,” Joseph said.
Holder says he tried to walk
away, but Deen threatened him, spit on him, and then pushed him once or twice.
“Deen walks fast back to his car
like he’s going to get a baseball bat,” Joseph said. “Hayden walked right
behind him, and blocked him from opening the door. Hayden is screaming, ‘Why
did you push me!’”
Holder's lawyer contends that he
was being pursued by Deen, who had a blood alcohol level of .26 at the time of
the attack.
Holder, who had also been
drinking, said Deen then took a swing at him. Holder then dropped Deen with a
left.
As Holder kept punching Deen,
some onlookers shouted, “Stop!” Others egged him on.
Holder said he doesn’t remember
hitting Deen more than once, and admits he was drunk, too.
“He kept taunting and threatening
me, he took a swing at me, and I guess I just lost it,” he said.
Holder's family saw their son's
charges reduced after grand jury testimony in 2014, but lawyers for Deen say
that Holder was no longer acting defensively when he continued his attack.
Holder said he doesn’t remember
hitting Deen more than once, and admits he was drunk, too.
Holder's family saw their son's
charges reduced after grand jury testimony in 2014, but lawyers for Deen say
that Holder was no longer acting defensively when he continued his attack.
Holder testified in front of a
grand jury. In March 2014, prosecutors reduced the charge against him from
attempted murder to first-degree assault, which carries a sentence of up to 25
years. He’s been in jail for over two years without bail. His trial is
scheduled to begin on April 29.
Holder grew up in Queens and went
to Hillcrest High School, before working as a home health aide and as a
mechanic at an AAMCO garage.
He could have a tough road in
court. The video itself is damning enough, and the fact that he hit Deen so
many times weakens any self-defense case. In addition, it’s going to be hard to
convince a jury that he blacked out and can’t remember repeatedly hitting Deen.
Now retired from the 32nd
Precinct in Washington Heights, Deen declined to comment. But Ed Mullins,
president of the Sergeants Benevolent Association, said Holder’s claims don’t
change the fact that he viciously beat Deen.
There’s a point in the video of
no return,” Mullins said. “Once he continues to strike, he goes from being
defensive to being offensive and that’s a crime. He had options.”
grayman@nydailynews.com
No comments:
Post a Comment