Never mind how many cops are killed each year...tell us how many people cops kill each year
Ex-Chicago cop sentenced to life in prison for grisly murder plot
Georgia deputy off duty as police investigate girlfriend’s bizarre shooting death while in bed together
Cop Previously Charged With Stalking Shoots and Kills Ex-Girlfriend
Ex-Chicago
cop sentenced to life in prison for grisly murder plot
By Jason Meisner Chicago
Tribunecontact the reporter
Ex-Chicago cop who planned to
extort businessman, then kill him, chop up his body gets life plus five years.
Ex-Chicago cop Steven Mandell
gets life plus five years in prison.
Steven Mandell delivers bizarre
remarks, including cheerfully wishing the judge a merry Christmas
After decades of drama in
Chicago, including a murder conviction, death sentence, shocking exoneration
and landmark lawsuit against the FBI, all Steven Mandell says he wanted to do
was quietly live out his golden years in Florida.
"I was happily retired,
living with my lovely wife in a golf course community in Naples," Mandell,
64, said Thursday as he delivered bizarre remarks at his sentencing in a packed
federal courtroom. "It was the perfect life."
Instead,he came out of
retirement in 2012 and returned to Chicago, where he was soon arrested in a
grisly plot to kidnap, murder and dismember a suburban businessman. Mandell
said he was once again framed by an untrustworthy informant, continuing his
"long FBI nightmare."
But U.S. District Judge Amy St.
Eve was unmoved by the melodrama. Moments after the former Chicago cop wrapped
up more than 30 minutes of mostly rambling remarks — including cheerfully
wishing the judge a merry Christmas — St. Eve sentenced him to life in prison
for kidnapping and extortion conspiracy and added a mandatory five-year
sentence for a gun conviction.
It was an emphatic end for
Mandell, a reputed underworld figure whom law enforcement has long considered a
dangerous killer and elusive target.8
Years ago Mandell — who then
went by the name Steven Manning — was sent to death row for the drug-related
1990 slaying of a trucking firm owner. After his murder conviction was
overturned on appeal, he won a landmark $6.5 million verdict in a lawsuit
against the FBI. A judge, however, later threw out the verdict, and Mandell
never collected a penny.
Mandell moved to Florida after
the ruling and vanished from the public eye. Several years later, he came back
to Chicago under his new name and soon was meeting with reputed mobsters at La
Scarola restaurant on Grand Avenue, according to court records.
Engel haned himself in his jail
cell shortly after he and Mandell were arrested, authorities said.In the videos
played at Mandell's February trial, he laughed when he described how victims
often come unglued before their deaths. He mimed a blindfolded prisoner, then
drew a hand across his throat to signify a killing. He seemed to have mirth in
his eyes as he made moaning sounds describing the carnage he could inflict.
"Uhhhh please ...
aaaaaaahhhh! It's pitiful," Mandell said in one recording.
Mandell's attorney, Francis
Lipuma, sought as few as 12 years in prison, saying Mandell should get credit
for the two decades he spent behind bars for a murder he didn't commit. Lipuma
noted that no one was actually harmed in the kidnapping plot and said if
Mandell were released in his 80s, he'd be at a point in his life "when
criminal activity would have concluded."
But in asking for a life
sentence, Assistant U.S. Attorney Amarjeet Bhachu painted Mandell as a sadistic
narcissist who "actually takes pleasure from hurting people."
"He likes it. It arouses him!"
said Bhachu, pointing to the defense table at Mandell, who took a sip of water
from a Styrofoam cup.
In her ruling, St. Eve said
Mandell's actions showed a "complete disregard for human life."
"The pure delight that you
showed in those videos … it came through loud and clear," St. Eve said.
"The glee in your face was very apparent. It was, quite frankly,
chilling."
St. Eve said a life sentence
was necessary to keep Mandell from returning to a life of violence and crime.
When FBI agents raided Mandell's
Buffalo Grove home after his arrest, they found more than $16,000 in cash in
two separate stashes as well as thousands of dollars more in a safe-deposit box
at a nearby bank, recent court filings show. Mandell has asked for the money to
be returned to his 83-year-old wife, but prosecutors have objected in sealed
filings.
Georgia
deputy off duty as police investigate girlfriend’s bizarre shooting death while
in bed together
Walton County Deputy Dwight
Buchanan, 21, reportedly loaded a pistol and handed it to his girlfriend,
20-year-old Nikki Guined, early Dec. 10 after a night of drinking and a fight.
But the two had reconciled and were in bed at the Monroe home, getting
'intimate,' when the shooting happened, according to police documents.
BY SASHA GOLDSTEIN
A Georgia deputy is on paid
leave as police investigate the bizarre shooting death of the man’s girlfriend
“while they were intimate” in bed following a fight.
Police say 20-year-old Nikki
Guined shot herself in the head early Dec. 10 following a night of drinking and
a fight with boyfriend Dwight Buchanan, a 21-year-old Walton County sheriff’s
deputy, according to WSB-TV.
She even said she would be “leaving
him” later that morning, but the couple made up and headed to bed at the
Monroe, Ga., home along Brentwood Boulevard, according to a report obtained by
the Atlanta Journal Constitution.
As the couple was “intimate,”
according to the report, “Nikki asked Dwight for his pistol. “Dwight was
reluctant to do so, but gave Nikki his unloaded pistol,” the document reads.
“Nikki repeatedly asked Dwight, 'Don't you trust me?' She then asked him to
load the pistol. Dwight took the pistol from Nikki, loaded it with a magazine
and chambered a round. He then removed the magazine and gave it back to Nikki.
She then placed the muzzle of the gun under her right jaw and pulled the
trigger."
Three other people at the home
heard the gunshot but did not hear the argument, according to the report.
The Georgia Bureau of
Investigation has been called in to investigate the strange death and Buchanan
is off the job during the inquiry.
He was hired 13 months ago and
worked at the Walton County jail.
"I wanted to be as
transparent as possible so that there are no questions,” Walton County Sheriff
Joe Chapman told WSB. "We don't want to appear that we're hiding
anything.”
The 9-mm. Glock pistol was
apparently a gift for Guined, Chapman told the Journal Constitution.
The house was reportedly strewn
with beer cans and the report says Guined was drinking, but doesn’t mention if
Buchanan had consumed alcohol.
An Instagram photo of the
smiling couple was posted on Dec. 10, the morning Guined died, with the caption,
“Even when he’s drunk he’s the cutest guy I’ve ever met. #lovehimsomuch.”
Cop
Previously Charged With Stalking Shoots and Kills Ex-Girlfriend
Rebecca Rose
A Philadelphia area cop with a
history of stalking was arrested for shooting and killing his ex-girlfriend on
Monday.
According to police, Colwyn
Borough police officer Stephen Rozniakowski, 32, shot and killed his former
girlfriend Valerie Morrow on Monday night at her home in Delaware County.
During the attack the victim's husband Tom Morrow, himself a police officer,
was also wounded. Police said Rozniakowski also shot and injured Morrow's
teenage daughter. Via 6ABC:
Delaware County District
Attorney Jack Whalen explains, "Tom Morrow, at this point hearing the
commotion, hearing the gunfire, reached into his nightstand next to the bed,
pulled out a revolver and started returning fire."
When he ran out of bullets
Morrow jumped out of a second floor window, breaking his ankle.
Tom Morrow and his teenage
stepdaughter were released from an area hospital after being treated for their
injuries. According to 6ABC, the motivation behind the shooting is believed to
be jealousy—Valerie Morrow and Rozniakowski were previously romantically
involved.
The Morrows reportedly believed
Rozniakowski was responsible for scratching their new car last week, leading
Valerie Morrow file for a protective order against him on Monday. The order was
delivered to Rozniakowki's home, where he lives with his mother, on Monday
evening at 6 p.m., reports 6ABC. After receiving the restraining order
Rozniakowski reportedly called and resigned as a police officer and then went
to the Morrow residence to confront his ex. Via the Delaware County Times:
Authorities said Rozniakowski,
who telephoned Colwyn Police Chief Bryan Hills Monday to resign from his part
time police position, was served a PFA at his residence in Norwood at about 6
p.m.
It was shortly after 9 p.m.
when shots rang out in the Glenfield Avenue home, killing an unidentified woman
[now identified as Valerie Morrow] and wounding a teenage girl.
Just when you thought this
story couldn't get any worse, it turns out local news reports exposed
Rozniakowski's stalking history more than nine months before the shooting at
the Morrow home, yet local police continued to keep him on their payroll
because officials believed his alleged criminal behavior was harmless.
According to NBC 10,
Rozniakowski was a bona fide scary-ass stalker, who was already facing dozens
of harassment and stalking related charges:
NBC10 Investigator Harry
Hairston put a spotlight on Rozniakowski earlier this year when the officer was
placed on "administrative leave" after his former fiancee filed a
protection from abuse order against him. Plymouth Township Police arrested
Rozniakowski and charged him with 25 counts of stalking and 50 counts of
harassment for allegedly contacting his former fiancee by phone and text
repeatedly.
The Delaware County Daily Times
reports Rozniakowski was on $100,000 bail in the wake of those stalking
charges:
Rozniakowski is facing trial in
Montgomery County, where he is accused of harassing and stalking another woman,
a former fiancee'. He is currently free on $100,000 unsecured bail in that case
— which includes 75 counts of stalking to cause fear, repeated harassment in an
anonymous manner and harassment in a course of conduct with no legitimate
purpose.
Rozniakowski's lawyer offered a
half-assed apology of sorts for his clients terrifying stalking behavior back
in April. "As a police officer, he knows the bounds and what the
boundaries are and what the laws are," said Marty Mullaney, an attorney
for Rozniakowski. "I think his emotions got the best of him."
NBC10 reported in April that
Rozniakowski was placed on paid administrative leave and given office duty.
According to NBC10's original report on Rozniakowski in April, Colwyn Borough
Police Chief Bryan Hills said he believed what Rozniakowski had done was
harmless and opted to let him remain on the job, receiving pay for office duty.
Rozniakowski was charged with 75 counts of harassing/stalking, yet his police
officer crony boss thought it was "harmless."
Chief Hills isn't the only
Colwyn Borough official with an utterly bullshit response to Rozniakowski's
abusive history. Emphasis mine:
Colwyn Borough Manager Paula
Brown told ABC6, "He was taken out of uniform and off the street back in
March of 2014 when the other issue surfaced. And he is not a Colwyn police
officer anymore, he resigned yesterday, and everything was taken care of
yesterday prior to the incident."
"Everything was taken care
of yesterday." Jesus, this attempt to cover their tracks in the wake of a
hideous failure could not be anymore insulting. Kudos to you for allowing a
stalker to remain on your payroll and then conveniently resign moments before
he killed a woman. What color would you like the balloons in your ticker tape
parade? Look, you can grasp at all the straws you want, but I doubt they are
going to be enough to cover all of the asses of everyone who spectacularly
failed to keep a killer from seeking revenge on his stalking victim.
The Delaware County Times notes
Rozniakowski's police-issued firearm was taken away after the protective order
was filed and is reportedly not the weapon used in the shooting death of
Morrow. Whalen is reportedly contemplating seeking the death penalty against
Rozniakowski, who faces murder charges. Meanwhile, Rozniakowski remains in
critical but stable condition at Crozer Chester Medical Center, under police
guard.
The real crime problem: Drunk and drugged up cops
Sierra Vista PD officer involved in on-duty crash while drunk
Hillsborough Police Officer Charged With DWI, Found Drunk And Asleep At The Wheel
Officer caught stumbling on camera, charged with DUI
Richmond officer found with marijuana in home likely won't face charges, officials say
Alcohol, prior drug use gets Utah police officer suspended
Sierra Vista cop causes accident, fired for intoxication
David Branov sentenced: Drug-addicted cop jailed for at least two-and-a-half years
Former Bronx cop sentenced on drug, other charges
Sierra
Vista PD officer involved in on-duty crash while drunk
Scott Oathout
SIERRA VISTA- A Sierra Vista
Police officer was fired Friday morning, after he was involved in a three
vehicle crash while under the influence of alcohol.
According to City of Sierra
Vista spokeswoman Judy Hector, Officer Joseph Arnason was driving his patrol
vehicle while on-duty around 6:56 a.m., when he rear-ended a vehicle on State
Route 92 near Buffalo Soldier Trail.
Nobody was injured in the
crash, but all three vehicles were damaged.
Following the crash, Officer
Arnason was required to submit to a drug and alcohol testing and found to be
intoxicated.
"The City of Sierra Vista
has a zero tolerance policy when it comes to drug and alcohol use on the job,
regardless of the position," said Chuck Potucek, city manager. "As
soon as I had confirmation that the officer was under the influence, I did not
hesitate to do what is right and dismiss the officer."
Officer Arnason was a 2-year
veteran with SVPD.
"The public has a right to
expect that the police officers responsible for helping keep the community safe
are themselves upholding the highest professional and ethical standards,"
said Tom Alinen, Chief of Police. "I am shocked and deeply saddened that
we have an officer who failed to meet these standards. This is a first in my 37
years with the City of Sierra Vista. But our residents can be assured that we
will take whatever steps are necessary to maintain the confidence our community
has that the Police Department puts the public's safety first."
The Arizona Department of
Public Safety has taken over the investigation of the crash.
Hillsborough
Police Officer Charged With DWI, Found Drunk And Asleep At The Wheel
Somerville police arrested and
charged a Hillsborough police officer with driving while intoxicated last
month.
By Carly Kilroy (Patch
Staff)December 16, 2014 at 11:28am
Somerville police arrested and
charged a Hillsborough police officer with driving while intoxicated after they
found him asleep behind the wheel in the middle of a lane at the intersection
of East Main and North Bridge streets last month. Officer Richard J. Yock was
found asleep in his 2005 silver GMC Envoy around 1 a.m. on Nov. 20, according
to nj.com.
Officer
caught stumbling on camera, charged with DUI
SOUTHWEST MIAMI-DADE, Fla.
(WSVN) -- A South Florida police officer was arrested for DUI after being
caught on camera veering through traffic and hitting an 18-wheeler, and a
witness said he never should have been on the road in the first place.
On Monday around 4 p.m., a
concerned citizen noticed a dangerous driver and began following the vehicle,
only to find out the driver was a police officer in uniform with a gun on his
waist.
The witness, who chose to
remain anonymous, said it was obvious that the officer was under the influence.
"He was obviously intoxicated," he said.
The man said he spotted the
officer in a silver Nissan driving erratically. "He was veering in and off
lanes; he was obviously driving under the influence," he said.
The witness then dialed 911,
followed the officer until he crashed his vehicle on Southwest 137th Avenue
after, the man said, the officer side-swiped an 18-wheeler.
As the driver and officer
pulled over, the witness pulled out his cell phone and began recording the
encounter. "Then we he got out of the car. I saw the gun on the right
side, the Taser gun on the left side," he said.
Hialeah Gardens Police
confirmed that 51-year-old Angel Gonzalez was the officer behind the wheel.
"He's under the influence, he's carrying a gun, he has the badge, I
wouldn't want to be the truck driver in that spot," the witness said.
Miami-Dade Police worked the
crash and stated in their report, "It was noted that the defendant had an
odor of an alcoholic beverage on his breath, his eyes were glassy, his gait was
unsteady, and his speech was thick-tongued."
When asked if he had been
drinking, the report stated, "the defendant denied drinking but stated
that he took Xanax."
According to the report,
Gonzalez failed a field sobriety test and refused a breathalyzer. He was
subsequently charged with DUI. "If this incident helps the police officer
realize that he has a problem, then I think that I did well for him," said
the witness.
Hialeah Gardens Police had no
comment on the matter but did say that Gonzalez has since been suspended from
the force.
Richmond
officer found with marijuana in home likely won't face charges, officials say
By Rick Hurd rhurd
RICHMOND -- A Richmond police
officer found with marijuana in his home earlier this year likely won't be
charged with a crime, authorities said, but his future on the police force is
undetermined. Veteran K-9 officer Joe Avila has been on paid administrative
leave since September, pending an internal investigation, officials in the
Richmond Police Department said. The
Contra Costa County District Attorney's Office has been investigating since the
case came to its attention earlier this year but is not inclined to file
charges, said Robin Lipetzky, the county's chief public defender. According to
Lipetzky, the decision likely stems from evidence not strong enough to produce
a conviction ALTHOUGH THE DOPE WAS FOUND IN HIS HOUSE.
Alcohol,
prior drug use gets Utah police officer suspended
By NATE CARLISLE
Before he was a police cadet, Brandon Done
suffered a back injury and took a co-worker’s medication to help him cope with
the pain.
Done should have reported the
illegal prescription use on his application to Weber State University’s police
academy, but he didn’t. Done later admitted the prescription use in an
employment application. The previous omission was reported to the Utah Peace
Officer Standards and Training Council, which regulates police.
Done went before the council
earlier this month and asked for a more lenient penalty than the two-year
suspension proposed.
"I want to get a job in
law enforcement," Done told the council, according to an audio recording
of its Dec. 8 meeting. "It is a career path I have always wanted to
do."
But the council suspended Done’s police
certification for two years. The council also suspended eight other current and
former peace officers.
The council gave a two-year
suspension to another peace officer, Shawnn Hartley, who failed to disclose
marijuana use. Hartley admitted after graduating from the academy that he had
used marijuana, according to information presented to the council. Hartley was
unemployed when he made the admission.
The council also suspended two
Cedar City police officers. Charles Crosby admitted to having sex with a woman
while he was on duty and in uniform, according to information provided to the
council. He was suspended for three years.
The other Cedar City officer,
Jed P. Imlay, was suspended for four years. According to information provided
to the council earlier this year Imlay drove his patrol car to a baseball park
with his son in the car and hit a retaining wall. Imlay then left the ballpark.
The police department investigated, determined Imlay was drunk and he pleaded
guilty to a misdemeanor count of driving under the influence. He was sentenced
to probation and two days in jail.
Another former police officer,
Troy Anderson, was suspended for 2 1/2 years for driving under the influence.
It was Anderson’s second offense. A judge in Box Elder County Justice Court
sentenced Anderson to two days in jail.
Other officers suspended at the
Dec. 8 meeting:
• Logan: Jacob Boehme,
six-month suspension for disorderly conduct and misuse of a police database.
• Tooele: Talisa Black,
two-year suspension for assault and domestic violence in the presence of a
child.
• Sandy: Jared Hughes, 18-month
suspension for driving under the influence.
• Utah Department of
Corrections: Mark D. Puett, six-month suspension for criminal mischief.
Sierra
Vista cop causes accident, fired for intoxication
SIERRA VISTA— A Sierra Vista
police officer has been fired after causing a traffic accident this morning
while operating his patrol vehicle under the influence of alcohol.
Officer Joseph Arnason had
checked on duty and was on his way to the shift briefing at 6:56 a.m. when he
rear-ended a vehicle on Highway 92, near Buffalo Soldier Trail, totaling the
patrol vehicle and causing a chain reaction that damaged two other vehicles,
according to a press release from the city. There were no injuries reported on
scene. In accordance with city policy, the officer was required to submit for
drug and alcohol testing and was found to be intoxicated. “The city of Sierra Vista has a zero
tolerance policy when it comes to drug and alcohol use on the job, regardless
of the position,” Sierra Vista City Manager Chuck Potucek said. “As soon as I
had confirmation that the officer was under the influence, I did not hesitate
to do what is right and dismiss the officer.”
The Arizona Department of
Public Safety was immediately called in to conduct an independent criminal
investigation, which is currently ongoing, the release states.
“The public has a right to
expect that the police officers responsible for helping keep the community safe
are themselves upholding the highest professional and ethical standards,”
Police Chief Tom Alinen said. “I am shocked and deeply saddened that we have an
officer who failed to meet these standards. This is a first in my 37 years with
the city of Sierra Vista. But our residents can be assured that we will take
whatever steps are necessary to maintain the confidence our community has that
the police department puts the public’s safety first.”
Officer Arnason was a two-year
veteran with the department.
David
Branov sentenced: Drug-addicted cop jailed for at least two-and-a-half years
Wayne Flower
A DIRTY cop who protected
criminals and sold them confidential information to feed a raging drug habit
will spend at least 2½ years behind bars.
David Branov, 42, said trauma
he experienced on the job led him to turn to ice, and when it became a daily
habit he turned to crime to pay for it.
But a County Court judge said
Branov’s problems offered no excuse for his crimes and did little to reduce his
moral culpability.
Branov pleaded guilty to 15
charges, including two counts of misconduct in public office, three counts of
theft, including of thousands of dollars of worth of methylamphetamine from
Fitzroy police station, attempting to pervert justice, and weapons and drugs
charges.
In sentencing Branov to four
years, three months and 28 days in jail, Judge Gavan Meredith condemned the
former senior constable for his gross breach of trust.
“Your role was to enforce the
law, not exploit it,” he said.
Judge Meredith said Branov must
be punished for undermining confidence in police.
The court heard Branov was
among at least three officers accused of taking bribes to turn a blind eye to
drug crimes.
The court heard that an
associate paid the trio $3000, which they split, to let him go after they
arrested him on drug charges.
Branov, an officer of seven
years’ standing, sold personal details, including driver’s licence details and
criminal records intelligence, and teamed up with a drug dealer mate to help
run a large-scale drug operation in 2009.
He was paid to tip off people
under surveillance and throw investigations off course.
Branov also hacked high-level
police databases to provide associates with details about his drug associates
and drug clients.
During his plea hearing, his
lawyer, Stewart Bayles, told the court Branov started using ice to help him get
through tough days on the beat.
He said that as a police
officer Branov suffered because of exposure to a number of events and
experiences that had had a traumatic effect on him.
But Judge Meredith said his
issues offer no excuse.
“Your motive does little to
reduce your moral culpability,” he said.
Former
Bronx cop sentenced on drug, other charges
NEW YORK. (WABC) --
A former police officer in the
Bronx was sentenced Wednesday on drug related and other charges.
Jose Ramos was sentenced to a
minimum 12 and a half years and a maximum of 14 and a half years in prison.
He was convicted on grand
larceny, robbery and drug possession charges.
The New York City Police
Department former officer was the original target of an undercover probe that
began in 2008, stemming from a tip about drug dealing and other illegal
activities at Ramos' family-owned barbershop in the Bronx.
The probe started when Ramos
was allegedly caught on a wiretap talking about fixing tickets.
Undercover video captured Ramos
using a police car to drive a shipment of supposed drugs from the Bronx to
Brooklyn.
"I don't deny I've done
wrong," said a contrite and tearful Jose Ramos, who begged a Bronx
criminal court judge for leniency Wednesday afternoon saying: "I take full
responsibility for my actions."
That's a far cry from a defiant
veteran cop who spoke with me exclusively in a jailhouse interview from Rikers
in February of 2012.
("You're accused of
dealing drugs, robbing people, shaking them down," we said.)
"Never," he said. ("None of that.") "None of
that," said Ramos.
Ramos was arrested in October
of 2011 with more than a dozen other cops accused in a ticket fixing scandal.
But the 40th precinct officer
was slapped with additional, far more serious charges including conspiring with
drug dealers.
He was convicted in October of
attempted robbery and drug possession, prosecutors saying Ramos agreed to take
$10,000 to transport what he thought was heroin.
In a damning video, part of an
undercover sting, Ramos, in full uniform, reassures an informant not to worry
about police checkpoints.
"To be honest with you, my
heart didn't skip a beat," he says. "Are you out of your mind?,"
said the informant. "You don't know the power of the blue," said
Ramos.
The judge gave the former cop a
minimum of 12 and a half years in prison saying: "You have utterly
disgraced your badge, your uniform, and your oath to uphold the law."
Several of Ramos' family
members, including his daughter, left in tears, as his attorney maintained the
officer never denied wrongdoing..
"How can you say he didn't
deny it. He told me he didn't do anything," we asked.
"He did things that were
offensive that he shouldn't have as a police officer, but he didn't do the
things from the very beginning the DA said he did," said attorney Matt
Kruger.
The DA says Ramos did even
more. He's also accused of conspiring to murder a witness.
In 179 fatalities involving on-duty NYPD cops in 15 years, only 3 cases led to indictments — and just 1 conviction
A Daily News analysis of
NYPD-involved deaths starts with the 1999 slaying of unarmed Amadou Diallo in a
hail of bullets in the Bronx and ends with last month’s shooting death of Akai
Gurley in a Brooklyn stairwell. Where race was known, 86% were black or Hispanic.
BY Sarah Ryley
, Nolan Hicks ,
Thomas Tracy , John Marzulli
, Dareh Gregorian /
A Staten Island grand jury’s decision not to
indict white NYPD Officer Daniel Pantaleo for the chokehold death of Eric
Garner — a black father of six — stunned large swaths of the city and added
fuel to a nationwide surge of protests over police killings.
But history shows the odds were
always in Pantaleo’s favor.
A Daily News investigation
found that at least 179 people were killed by on-duty NYPD officers over the
past 15 years. Just three of the deaths have led to an indictment in state
court. In another case, a judge threw out the indictment on technical grounds
and it was not reinstated.
Only one officer who killed
someone while on duty has been convicted, but he was not sentenced to jail
time.
The analysis of the
police-involved deaths begins with the 1999 slaying of unarmed Amadou Diallo in
a hail of bullets and ends with last month’s shooting death of Akai Gurley, who
police say was hit by a ricocheting bullet fired by a rookie cop in a darkened
housing project stairwell in Brooklyn. Gurley was also unarmed.
The News found that since 1999:
Roughly 27% of people killed by cops were
unarmed..
Where race was known, 86% were black or
Hispanic..
Twenty-one people were killed — three of them
by off-duty cops — in 2012, the highest during the 15-year span..
Former NYPD Officer Bryan
Conroy was convicted in 2005 of criminally negligent homicide for gunning down
West African immigrant Ousmane Zongo, 43, during a counterfeit goods raid at a
Chelsea warehouse two years earlier.
Zongo — a married father of two who was never
implicated in the counterfeit goods investigation — worked at the warehouse and
happened upon Conroy, who was disguised as a postal worker when he drew his
weapon. Conroy shot Zongo four times.
Conroy’s first trial ended in a
hung jury. A judge convicted him in a second trial and sentenced him to five
years of probation and 500 hours of community service.
“In most of those cases it
would be the local district attorney who’s bringing up the charges, if any,”
said Robert Gangi, executive director of the Prison Reform Organizing Project.
“There’s an inherent conflict
of interest. . . . The police and DA work very closely together, and so they
need each other to carry out their jobs,” said Gangi, adding he’s encouraged by
the mainstream political support from Gov. Cuomo to state Assembly members to
create a special prosecutor who would handle police-involved deaths.
The News’ analysis was based on
information compiled by organizations such as the Prison Reform Organizing
Project and the Stolen Lives Project, the NYPD’s annual firearms discharge
reports, press reports, and court documents. The News only included deaths that
involved an active member of the force and were a direct result of the
officer’s actions. So, cases where individuals died from swallowing drugs
during an arrest or hitting a tree during a car chase, for example, were not
included.
The News found 222 deaths total
during the 15-year span — 43 of which involved off-duty officers, some of whom
bravely stepped in when they saw trouble, others who were embroiled in personal
disputes or driving drunk. The News was only able to identify 10 convictions
covering 14 of those off-duty deaths, and one case that is ongoing.
Patrick Lynch, head of the
Patrolmen’s Benevolent Association, pointed out that during the same time
period, nearly 80 officers have been killed in the line of duty, a number that
includes cops who heroically died in the Sept. 11 terrorist attack and from
related health complications.
“When there is a life-or-death
situation on the street, be it an armed robbery, a homicidal maniac on the
street or someone driving a vehicle in a dangerous and potentially deadly way,
it is New York City police officers who step in and take the risk away from the
public and put it on themselves,” Lynch said in a statement. “Our work has
saved tens of thousands of lives by assuming the risk and standing between New
Yorkers and life-threatening danger.”
The NYPD declined to comment
for this article or provide its own internal statistics on officer-involved
deaths, and the information has not been submitted to the FBI since 2006.
Commissioner Bill Bratton
defended his department in a recent interview on “Good Day New York,” saying,
“We have some of the lowest number of incidents of taking lives in this
country.”
Some of the deaths reviewed by
The News involved fierce firefights and death-defying heroism by New York’s
Finest — like when off-duty Officer Ivan Marcano, on a night out with his
girlfriend, took down an armed robber as he clutched his own gunshot wound to
the chest. Marcano was later honored by President Obama.
There’s an inherent conflict of
interest. . . . The police and DA work very closely together, and so they need
each other to carry out their jobs.
Officer Richard Burt gunned
down assassin Othneil Askew in 2003 after Askew murdered Councilman James Davis
in City Hall. Four rookie cops took down hatchet-wielding madman Zale Thompson
in Jamaica, Queens, in October.
But in more than a quarter of
the on-duty fatalities the victim was unarmed — some were cases of mistaken
identity or innocent bystanders. Others like Garner were implicated in
low-level crimes (he was accused of selling untaxed cigarettes).
And roughly 20% involved people
who were emotionally disturbed, such as Iman Morales, who in 2008 was found
naked and waving a fluorescent bulb on the second-floor ledge of a building on
Tompkins Ave. in Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn. Cops tried to subdue him with a
Taser, and Morales fell headfirst onto the concrete below and died.
Lt. Michael Pigott, who ordered
the use of the Taser, took his own life eight days later.
“I have never in 30 years met
any police officers who, as he drove into work, said, ‘Today I am going to get
into a shooting, kill someone, become a headline and lose my job and my
pension,’ ” said Ed Mullins, the president of the Sergeants Benevolent Association.
Mullins said many people don’t
realize the lifetime impact a death has on officers.
“Their personality changes. . .
. They become quiet. They go about their business, but they’re not the same
people they used to be.”
Diallo, an African immigrant, was
standing in the vestibule of his Bronx apartment building when four white
anti-crime cops mistook him for a rape suspect. They ordered him to show his
hands; Diallo tried to show them his wallet. The officers mistook it for a gun,
and 41 bullets later, the 22-year-old was dead.
The officers were acquitted of
murder charges a year later — setting off a sea of protests, new police
training procedures and numerous studies of how racial bias influences snap
decisions on whether to shoot.
Amadou Diallo was fatally shot
by NYPD officers Feb. 4, 1999, in the Bronx. Amadou Diallo was fatally shot by
NYPD officers Feb. 4, 1999, in the Bronx.Patrick Dorismond, March 16, 2000, in
Manhattan. Timothy Stansbury, Jan. 24, 2009, in Brooklyn. Leonel Disla,Oct. 30,
2005, in the Bronx. Fermin Arzu, May 18, 2007, in the Bronx. Jayson Tirado,
Oct. 21, 2007, in Manhattan.
But the number of on-duty
police killings has not gone down. The News tallied 11 in 1999, the year Diallo
was killed, and 12 this year. In 2012, there were 18, the highest during the
15-year span.
“There’s a lot of frustration,”
said lawyer Norman Siegel, a longtime advocate of reforming the grand jury
system.
The Garner case was a rare
instance in which video clearly showed the chain of events leading up to a
death. Garner protested what he perceived as harassment, saying, “I can’t
breathe” 11 times as he was put into a chokehold and piled on by several
officers.
The shocking video of the
chokehold that led to Garner’s death on July 17 in Tompkinsville, S.I., was
first published by NYDailyNews.com.
The medical examiner’s office
ruled his death a homicide caused by the chokehold. Obesity was a contributing
factor in the 43-year-old man’s death, the medical examiner found.
There have been other cases
where unarmed civilians died after being choked or having their chests
compressed by officers where there were no such videos — and no public outrage
and no grand jury hearings.
James Young, a 49-year-old
father of three, fell into a coma and later died after he was choked by a
narcotics detective “for an extended period of time” until he started foaming
at the mouth and lost consciousness, a lawsuit claims. The Brooklyn district
attorney declined to prosecute the case, and the civil lawsuit was settled for
$832,500 in June.
Siegel, who represented Young’s
widow, said the Garner case demonstrates that even a damning video does not
guarantee accountability.
“A video might have been
helpful in James Young’s case, but the real problem is still the secret grand
jury process and the lack of a special prosecutor,” Siegel said.
A mentally ill woman, Shereese
Francis, 29, of Queens, died of heart failure in 2012 after being suffocated by
four male officers who were called to get her in an ambulance because she
hadn’t been taking her meds, another lawsuit claims.
After a 14-month investigation
that included several home visits and interviews with family members who were
present on the day of the death, the Queens DA declined to prosecute, according
to court records. The family was awarded $1.1 million in a civil lawsuit in
May.
The family’s lawyer said her
death was ruled a homicide due to compression of the chest. She, like Garner,
was obese, and the cops applied a chokehold on her for a short time as well,
lawyer Steve Vaccarro said.
New York prosecutors, like
their counterparts across the nation, have had difficulties scoring indictments
against cops.
In Manhattan — where The News
found 41 deaths involving on-duty cops since 1999 — the prosecutor who got the
conviction in the Zongo case, former Manhattan DA Robert Morgenthau, had a
policy to present all cases involving fatal shootings by cops to a grand jury.
It’s a policy that’s being continued by his successor, Cyrus Vance Jr.
“I wanted people to have
confidence in the integrity of law enforcement and the criminal justice
system,” Morgenthau told The News. “If I would pick and choose the cases,
people would lack confidence in the objectivity of the prosecutor.”
A video might have been helpful
in James Young’s case, but the real problem is still the secret grand jury
process and the lack of a special prosecutor.
Some controversial cases in
Brooklyn — where The News found 75 deaths involving on-duty officers — never
made it to a grand jury, despite promises from former District Attorney Charles
Hynes that they were under active investigation. Instead, those cases withered
on the vine, preventing police from proceeding with departmental investigations
and the victims’ families from proceeding with civil cases.
“I’m very upset my son’s case
never reached a grand jury,” said Laverne Dobbinson, whose son Tamon Robinson
was fatally struck by an NYPD cruiser in April 2012 as cops chased him for
stealing rocks from the grounds of a housing project in Canarsie, Brooklyn.
“It was just swept under the
rug,” she said.
A probe into the July 11, 2009,
death of Army veteran Shem Walker dragged on for more than four years, as Hynes
said he was weighing how to proceed.
Walker, a married 49-year-old
Army vet, got into a scuffle with an undercover officer he’d tried to move from
the stoop of his grandmother’s building in Fort Greene. Walker didn’t know the
man was a cop observing a buy-and-bust operation nearby, and the altercation
got physical. Police said Walker punched the undercover, then the undercover
shot Walker three times.
It was Hynes’ successor,
Kenneth Thompson, who finally decided not to submit the case to a grand jury
earlier this year.
“There was absolutely no reason
that I can fathom for keeping these cases open for so long,” said the Walker
family’s lawyer, Scott Rynecki. “The fact that prior DA Hynes sat on these
cases for so long left no choice for the new DA because so much time had
passed. The families are entitled to closure.”
Hynes declined to comment.
Bronx DA Robert Johnson managed
to score a manslaughter indictment against Officer Richard Haste for the
shooting death of Ramarley Graham in 2012.
Haste said he’d followed Graham
into his E. 229th St. home as part of a drug investigation, and opened fire on
the 18-year-old when the teen reached for his waistband. No weapon was found.
But Johnson’s victory was
short-lived. A judge tossed the indictment, finding prosecutors made a mistake
in their presentation. He presented the case to a grand jury again, and said he
was “surprised and shocked” when the grand jury voted not to indict.
Queens District Attorney
Richard Brown prosecuted three officers for manslaughter and reckless endangerment
for the 2006 killing of Sean Bell — another death that sparked nationwide
protests. Bell was leaving his bachelor party at a Jamaica strip club with two
friends when cops unleashed a fusillade of 50 bullets at their gray Nissan
Altima.
The feds are investigating the
Graham and Garner cases for possible civil rights violations. But Siegel noted
it’s been two decades since the feds last prosecuted a fatal police case in New
York.
Anthony Baez, 29, was tossing a
football around with his brothers in the Bronx when the ball hit a squad car in
1994. Officer Frank Livoti became enraged and squeezed the life out of Baez
with a chokehold. A Bronx grand jury indicted him and he was acquitted by a
judge of criminally negligent homicide.
Livoti was convicted in 1998 of
federal civil rights violations and served nearly seven years in prison.
Siegel said the Garner case
would be more difficult for the feds because Garner was a criminal suspect,
albeit a very low-level one.
As for the shooting death of
Gurley, who was laid to rest Saturday, sources told The News that Thompson will
empanel a grand jury by the end of the month to consider possible charges
against rookie cop Peter Liang.
Several state and local
politicians, meanwhile, have called for a special prosecutor to handle all
cases where people have been killed by police, believing local district
attorneys can’t pursue them objectively because they work so closely with cops.
Editor's note: The News added
that the 80 officers killed in the line of duty over the past 15 years, a
figure provided by the Patrolmen's Benevolent Association, include those who
died of illnesses related to their work after the Sept. 11 terrorist attack.
The epidemic of mentally ill cops
Dalton police officer charged with child molestation
Bryan reserve officer charged with indecency with a child, 58 counts of child pornography
Daniel Guadalupe: Retired NYPD officer accused of raping teenage girl for years in Palm Beach County
Las Cruces cop gets lengthy prison sentence for sex with minor
Irwindale Cop Pleads No Contest To Sex Charges Involving 2 Teenage Girls
Dalton
police officer charged with child molestation
Jon Gargis
The Atlanta
Journal-Constitution
A recently sworn-in Dalton
police officer is off the job following his arrest Thursday on a child
molestation charge.
The Georgia Bureau of
Investigation arrested Officer Daniel Tolbert just after 5 p.m., Dalton police
spokesman Bruce Frazier said Thursday night. The arrest came nine days after
the department placed Tolbert on administrative leave immediately after being
informed by the GBI and the Whitfield County Sheriff’s Office that he was under
investigation on suspicion of child molestation.
“I am very disappointed to hear
about this allegation, and upset about the discredit this will surely bring on
our department and officers,” Dalton Police Chief Jason Parker said in a news
release Thursday. “We would never condone or support the kind of behavior that
would warrant this charge. The men and women of this department hold ourselves
to a very high standard of behavior, and we know the community we serve expects
our behavior to be beyond reproach.”
Though police officials did not
have specifics on the allegations against Tolbert, Frazier said the alleged
incident did not occur while Tolbert was on the job. At the time of his
suspension, he was in the department’s field training program, and as a
trainee, he was never unsupervised or alone while on duty. Probationary
trainees, Frazier added, ride with an experienced training officer for at least
four months after completing the police academy.
Tolbert, 32, completed the
police academy in September and was sworn in as an officer on Sept. 16. Though
Tolbert is currently on administrative leave, the city will begin the
termination process immediately, Frazier said.
Prior to joining Dalton’s
police force, Tolbert served in the U.S. Army, the U.S. Border Patrol in
California and was a jail deputy with the Clayton County Sheriff’s Office,
according to the police department’s blog.
Former
Bryan reserve officer charged with indecency with a child, 58 counts of child
pornography
By ANDREA SALAZAR
andrea.salazar@theeagle.com |
A former Bryan reserve police
officer was indicted Thursday on 58 counts of child pornography and one count
of indecency with a child.
Dennis Fraley, 62, was among 34
people indicted by a Brazos County grand jury during its bi-monthly meeting to
determine whether there is enough evidence to move forward with prosecution.
Texas Rangers and Brazos County sheriff’s deputies took him into custody
Thursday evening.
Fraley was out on $45,000 bail
at the time. He had been arrested in September on three counts of possession of
child pornography, which is a third-degree felony punishable by up to 10 years
in prison, after a friend noticed inappropriate photographs on Fraley’s phone
while helping him install an application, according to the probable cause
affidavit for the arrest.
Fraley resigned from the Bryan
Police Department following his September arrest, during which he told
investigators he had “arrested people like him” and that he “had been sick for
a couple of years,” according to the court document.
The grand jury also indicted
two men Thursday accused of robbing a College Station Holiday Inn in November
2012.
Denzel Neal, 21, and
Christopher Elmore, 22, were each charged with one count of first-degree felony
aggravated robbery in connection with the 2012 incident in which the men
reportedly emptied a hotel cash register after threatening the clerk with a
gun, according to the probable cause affidavit for their arrest.
The clerk told police the men
had asked for jumper cables before one revealed a pistol in the waist of his
pants when the clerk said he could not leave the front desk, investigators said
in the report.
Both admitted to robbing the
hotel two years ago while on their way to Austin, police said.
Other offenses on this week’s
indictment list included state jail felony drug charges and second-degree
felony aggravated assault and burglary.
Daniel
Guadalupe: Retired NYPD officer accused of raping teenage girl for years in
Palm Beach County
A retired NYPD officer is under
arrest, accused of raping a teenage girl over several years in suburban Boynton
Beach.
Daniel Guadalupe, 56, is facing
charges of sexual battery, lewd or lascivious molestation and false
imprisonment. He is being held on $250,000 bail at the Palm Beach County Jail.
According to an arrest
affidavit, Guadalupe sexually assaulted the now-17-year-old victim beginning
when she was in eighth grade, and continuing though the summer between her
freshman and sophomore year.
The victim told investigators
that the situation escalated from inappropriate touching to Guadalupe forcing
her to have sex with him. She said that she has been suppressing her memories
of the abuse.
She described to investigators
about one incident in which he held her down and sexually assaulted her, during
which time she struggled to get away. She recalled he said to her afterwards,
"Did you really have to put up that much of a fight, it doesn't really
have to be that way," and to "just get over it."
She said that over the years
she would give in to his demands just to get him to stop.
On Wednesday, one of the
victim's relatives confronted Guadalupe in a controlled phone call with PBSO
investigators present. On the call he made numerous admissions and apologized
for getting "carried away playing around."
Former
Las Cruces cop gets lengthy prison sentence
LAS CRUCES (AP) – A former Las
Cruces police detective faces a lengthy prison term after being sentenced in a
sex case involving minors.
State District Judge Fernando
Macias on Monday sentenced former Detective Michael Garcia to 30 years in
prison but suspended 10 years of the sentence.
Garcia was convicted of
multiple counts of criminal sexual contact of a minor.
He was initially arrested in
August 2013 and accused of sexually assaulting a minor and then arrested again
in September 2013 on additional charges involving another victim.
Garcia has already received a
nine-year federal sentence in a case involving a teenage girl who was an intern
with the Police Department in 2013.
The sentences will run at the
same time, with Garcia serving the federal sentence first.
Former
Irwindale Cop Pleads No Contest To Sex Charges Involving 2 Teenage Girls
LOS ANGELES (CBSLA.com) — A
former Irwindale police officer pleaded no contest Friday to sex-related
charges involving two girls in the department’s Explorer Program.
Daniel Camerano, 27, pleaded no
contest to three felony counts, including using a minor for sex acts, oral
copulation of a person under 16 and contact with a minor for sexual offense.
Los Angeles Superior Court
Judge Georgina Torres Rizk ordered Camerano not to have any contact with the
two girls.
Camerano, who is free on bond,
is expected to be sentenced Jan. 20 for two years and eight months in state
prison and to be ordered to register for the rest of his life as a sex
offender.
Three other charges filed
against him earlier this year are expected to be dismissed when he is
sentenced.
Camerano, who served as an
adviser to the department’s Explorer Program, resigned from the police
department in June after eight years on the force.
Prosecutors say Camerano began
a sexual relationship with the 14-year-old girl between May 2009 and December
2010 and sent suggestive text messages to 17-year-old girl in November 2012.
Both girls were in the department’s Explorer Program.
The charges against Camerano is
the third case against a former Irwindale police officer in just over a year.
Former officer David Paul
Fraijo pleaded no contest Oct. 3 to one count each of oral copulation under
color of authority and sexual battery by restraint involving a woman he pulled
over during an October 2012 traffic stop. He is facing up to nine years in
state prison, with sentencing set Jan. 12.
Another former officer, Dennis
Alva, pleaded no contest last September to a felony grand theft charge. He was
sentenced in November 2013 to one year in county jail and ordered to repay
$250,000 in cash to his elderly father.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




