Troy Police officer resigns after internal investigation


By Molly Eadie

TROY  Officer Michael Johnson has resigned after an internal investigation into his off-duty actions, while two of his colleagues have been suspended without pay for unrelated incidents, officals confirmed.
Officers Sean McMahon and Dominick Comitale were both suspended this week, months after two separate internal investigations concluded, officials say.
Johnson was suspended for 30 days without pay in March after accompanying a woman who was allegedly buying heroin in Hudson, according to sources with knowledge of the investigation. The woman was arrested, but Johnson did not face any charges.
Officials say Johnson’s last day was Friday.
Comitale’s actions were investigated after he was said to have videotaped a female patient at Samaritan Hospital who was under the influence of hallucinogenics, a violation of department protocol.
He had previously been investigated by the department for mishandling an incident with a former Hudson Valley Community College student and football player.
While assisting another officer in arresting the student for jaywalking, Comitale took the student’s cell phone after a scuffle while attempting to place him in handcuffs, and placed the phone in his patrol car.
He later informed then-Police Benevolent Association President Bob Fitzgerald that he’d lost the phone, and needed money to pay the student back before he left the area for his out-of-state hometown. Fitzgerald previously said he gave Comitale more than $800 in cash to reimburse the student and was later paid back by Comitale.
The investigation into McMahon concerned charges of excessive force used on Lawrence Nesmith, 48, of Troy. Nesmith was reportedly injured and bloodied after handcuffs were placed on him in the department’s holding cells, and the incident was recorded on the department’s cameras.